Do you know what one of the hardest things about visiting China is?
As the most advanced surveillance state in the world, leveraging online privacy/anonymity in the country is an impossible feat to achieve. China’s system of high-tech spying is unescapable; someone is always watching you. It’s like you’re roaming around naked, digitally. Excuse the bad example lol 😛
That’s actually how I felt when I visited Mainland China two years ago. Also, I experienced “The Great Firewall” in all its might, which blocked me from accessing Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, WhatsApp, Gmail, and other Google services. I couldn’t even get a VPN that would work and unblock them.
Can you imagine my surprise? I was literally lost! The Chinese Government bans VPN services that are not state-approved. When I returned from China, I took it upon myself to discover VPNs that can bypass the Great Firewall (after all, I am an online privacy/security advocate at BestVPN.co).
So, without further ado, read this comprehensive Best VPN for China guide, where I discuss how I took 30 days, putting in 240+ hours, into the large-scale testing over 80+ providers, determining the top “working” choices for you!
How Does China Block Sites and VPNs via GFW?
In an attempt to strengthen Cybersecurity, the Chinese Government has passed several controversial laws; stifling political dissent, affecting communication technologies, the formation of international entities, eliminating “freedom of speech”, and affecting areas of academia to business and policymaking.
The country wants zero reliance on anything “outsider” and even takes action against services that could bypass their laws i.e. VPN China services. If you’re like me, this could trigger some curiosity, as to how is China doing this. So, continue reading, as I dissect the many methods of China’s censorship machine, diving into the technology behind the infamous “Great Firewall” a.k.a. GFW:
Let me warn you, things do get quite technical. I’ll try my best though to simplify it as much as possible…
IP Blocking i.e. Deploying a Blacklist
This method involves the creation of a blacklist that includes undesirable IP addresses. Routers drop all packets destined to blocked IPs, which in terms of privacy tools, includes the addresses of VPN sites.
DNS Tampering via DNS Poisoning
DNS-related blocking techniques work in conjunction with IP blocking. Those who indulge in the tampering of DNS addresses falsify the response returned by the DNS server via intentional configuration or DNS poisoning,
This DNS server can lie about associated IP addresses, authoritative servers for the domain, any CNAMEs related to the domain, or the existence of the domain itself.
China uses this tactic to map Facebook’s domain name to a false address. For the domain name facebook.com, only 1% of vantage points in China, return a mapping to 184.108.40.206, where 94.5% of all vantage points do around the world.
Upon digging further, it is visible that at least 71.1% of vantage points return a mapping to 220.127.116.11, an address that no other country’s servers return, which shows that China has poisoned Facebook’s domain name to a false address.
DNS Hijacking – Injecting Fake DNS
Apart from DNS tampering, routers can disrupt unwanted communication through any channel by hijacking DNS requests containing banned keywords and injected forged DNS replies.
According to researchers, China uses a blocklist of around 15,000 keywords with injections of fake DNS, which block sites even when you utilize a third-party DNS resolver outside the country.
Other More Advanced Techniques
- Collateral DNS Damage – When China deploys DNS injections, their Firewall does not separate incoming/outgoing traffic, resulting in large-scale collateral DNS damage. According to research, 15,225 open-resolvers outside China were affected in about 79 countries.
- Deep Packet Inspect (DPI) – Working in coordination with an Intrusion Detection System (IDS), China uses DPI for the instant analyzing of connections and blocking, re-routing, or logging it accordingly. All packets incoming to China pass through their Firewall, making blocking of VPN connections easier and less disruptive.
Blocking VPN Services
“Blackholing” VPN Servers
The fire line of defense for China against VPNs is to blackhole websites and services using BGP. A Protocol designed to allow routers to communicate efficiently and inform which resources are and aren’t available to other routers.
Blackholing prevents the TLS handshake from completing, which in turn mitigates the protection offered by VPNs, eventually adding their IPs to their blacklist.
Most VPN providers have at least two to three servers blackholed by China.
CactusVPN, Keenow Unblocker, and VPNArea are a few examples. All of their servers are blackholed, making it impossible for users of these servers to connect in China.
Attacking the OpenVPN Protocol
OpenVPN (TCP and UDP) is a famous protocol for leveraging anonymity. It is most suited for countries with tough internet laws like China, Egypt, UAE, Iran, Iraq, Turkey, etc.
XOR Obfuscation used alongside the OpenVPN helps providers in bypassing VPN bans in such countries. Governments can’t shut OpenVPN down, due to its utility in enterprise networks.
However, China is getting increasingly clever at identifying unauthorized OpenVPN traffic, particularly those routing it through port 443, intended to disguise OpenVPN as HTTPS traffic.
TCP RST Floods to Shut Down Dissident Devices
The Chinese Government has also adapted towards tackling L2TP over IPSec, which in place of OpenVPN worked quite well, until a few years ago.
Many have experienced an instant blocking of connections deriving from L2TP over IPSec protocols because the GFW shuts them down using TCP RST Floods.
Of course, different configurations may help in bypassing the VPN block in China, but for now, it is safe to say that some modules provide weaker encryption and can be shut up.
5 Best VPN that Works in China!
Now that you are familiar with the technicalities behind the GFW system, I will give you some recommendations on VPNs that work in China.
I actually conducted a test on over 80+ providers, out of which only 15 were able to successfully bypass the GFW and its algorithms for VPN ban. Isn’t that surprising?
To make the decision-making process for users, I further shortlisted the 15. Below you will find recommendations on the 5 Best VPN China that work using various obfuscation techniques:
NordVPN (Does Nordvpn Work in China?)
Pros: 5228 servers in 62 countries worldwide. Six simultaneous connections. Unblocks VoDs like US Netflix and BBC iPlayer. Obfuscation for bypassing GFW in China.
Free trial available. Ad/Malware/Tracker blocker. Apps for all platforms/devices, including Android TVs. P2P/File Sharing allowed with specialized torrenting servers available.
Cons: Money back guarantees take 30 days. The monthly plan is costly.
Final Verdict: NordVPN is a Panamanian-based provider, which indicates it is completely free from the censored internet and government surveillance, as it is away from 5, 9, and 14 Eyes Alliances.
To our satisfaction, it also adopts a strong focus on privacy. The VPN boasts a no logs policy and provides military-grade, 256-bit AES encryption for maximum security.
At the same time, it offers all the advanced features to keep your identity anonymous. These include Automatic Kill Switch, DNS Leak/IPv6 Protection, Stealth Mode, Tor, and Double Hop!
Users in China can download NordVPN from their dedicated Chinese page here: http://nord-for-zh.com/
How to Bypass the GFW via NordVPN
In order to bypass the GFW using NordVPN, you will need to connect to their obfuscated servers, available only on their Windows and Android apps.
- Download the NordVPN Windows app
- Enter your login credentials to use the VPN
- Go to “Settings” and click on “Advanced Settings”
- Check the “I know what I am doing” box
- Enable the “Obfuscated Servers” option
- Enjoy bypassing VPN Blocks in China!
Pros: 2,000+ server’s network in 94 countries and 148 locations worldwide. Six simultaneous connections. Unblocks US Netflix and other VoDs. StealthVPN is available for bypassing GFW in China.
P2P/Torrenting support. 30-day money back guarantee. Split Tunneling and Automatic Kill Switch. Available on iOS, Mac, Windows, and Android.
Cons: Overall Expensive Service. No Port Forwarding Option.
Final Verdict: ExpressVPN is one of the leading privacy tools in the marketplace, offering unmatched security and privacy to users around the world. It is away from “Internet Enemy” jurisdictions.
The provider even offers a verified zero logs policy, which even the Turkish Authorities could not break, during an investigation concerning the assassination of the Russian Ambassador of Turkey.
Users in China can download ExpressVPN from their dedicated Chinese page here: http://exp4links4.net/
How to Bypass the GFW via ExpressVPN
In order to bypass the GFW using ExpressVPN, you will need to connect to their StealthVPN servers in Hong Kong, specifically designed to defeat censorship in China:
- Download the ExpressVPN Windows app
- Log into your account and enter the activation code
- Connect to servers designated for China Users (ask support team)
- For instance, Hong Kong – 2 uses Obfuscation
- Enjoy bypassing VPN blocks!
Pros: 800+ servers in 50 countries worldwide. MultiHop Feature for Boosting Anonymity. CleanWebTM (Ad/Tracker/Malware Blocker) Automatic Kill Switch and Wi-Fi Protection.
Budget-Friendly costs ($47.76 for 2 years). Legacy Simultaneous Connections (No Limits – USP of the provider). WhitelisterTM for specifying VPN connection on different apps/websites.
Cons: Support Needs Improvement. Uses Virtual Locations.
Final Verdict: Based in the British Virgin Islands, Surfshark just like the names above is located in a safe jurisdiction, where user privacy is respected and protected.
The newcomer has become quite famous in a short time, due to its ability to unblock VoDs and bypassing the GFW in China. Their apps and quite user-friendly and intuitive too!
Here is the redirection link to access the provider’s site in China: https://shark-cn.com/
How to Bypass the GFW via Surfshark
If you want to bypass the GFW using Surfshark, you will have to activate their “NoBordersTM Mode”, which offers extra security for enjoying the open internet without blocks/restrictions.
- Download the Surfshark Windows Application
- Subscribe to a plan and enter your login details in the app
- Click on the “Gear” icon on the top right corner
- Navigate to the “Advanced” settings menu
- Activate the “NoBordersTM Mode”
- Connect to any available servers!
Pros: 400+ servers in 115 cities across 64 countries. Unblocks US Netflix and BBC iPlayer UK. Five Simultaneous Connections. Smart Mode for activating VPN on specific sites.
Application Filter to choose which apps use VPN. WireGuard support is available. VPN sharing and App Guard. Automatic Kill Switch and StealthVPN for bypassing GFW in China.
Cons: No 24/7 Live Chat. Expensive monthly subscription.
Final Verdict: Based in Seychelles (away from 5, 9, and 14 Eyes Alliances), Astrill VPN is another reliable service for circumventing censorship and geo-restrictions in China.
The provider offers an undefeatable StealthVPN feature, which enables you to tunnel all sites and connect to specialized servers in different countries for access in China.
How to Bypass the GFW via Astrill VPN
- Download and Install the Astrill VPN Windows app
- Enter the login details after purchasing a subscription
- On the top right corner, click on “OpenVPN”
- From the list of options, select “StealthVPN”
- Select “Tunnel All Sites” Mode
- Connect to any specialized Server Available!
Pros: 3000+ servers in 50+ countries worldwide. OpenConnect SSL based VPN. Simultaneous Connections on Five Devices. StealthVPN for bypassing GFW in China.
Supports SOCKS5/SSH/HTTP/SSL. MITM attack protection. Secure G/PGP encryption. Perfect forward secrecy available. Dedicated IP addresses!
Cons: Based in an FVEY. Confusing Pricing Plans.
Final Verdict: Despite being based in the US, TorGuard tends to be quite a resilient service, offering users protection from the government’s mandatory data retention laws.
There have been zero instances of the provider cooperating with security agencies. Their security is unmatched and the availability of dedicated IPs further boosts its credibility.
How to Bypass the GFW via TorGuard
- Download and install the TorGuard application
- Enter your login details after subscribing
- Launch the app and head to the server listing
- Select any of the “Stealth” servers available
- Use the “UDP” protocol for max security
- Hit the “Connect” button!
An In-Depth Analysis of 80+ Providers for Bypassing GFW in China
You may think that finding a working VPN in China is a simple task. Oh hell no, it was not lol I faced great difficulty in testing VPNs and their reliability for bypassing the GFW in China.
Since I do not reside in the country, the task further became difficult. This urged me to get in contact with one of BestVPN.co’s representatives in Beijing, who has a rented server.
I downloaded WeChat so that I could be in-tune with all the tests on Video Call. My technical analysis and me, tested over 80 providers after the latest government purge.
Bear in mind large scale testing of VPNs is quite a difficult task, as anyone caught could be handed over to the Chinese authorities. So, I’m just glad our representative is safe.
Concerning the results, you can look at the Google Spreadsheet I created and embedded below. Here you can see 3 categories of VPNs in China: Active, Inconsistent, and Inactive.
Alternatives to Using a VPN in China
It is hard to doubt the usefulness of VPNs, particularly for unblocking VoD services and engaging in P2P/Torrenting. These privacy tools are the epitome of leveraging anonymity online.
Especially, in countries like China, where “The Great Firewall” bans access to all foreign services. Does this mean you should rely on VPNs entirely? Not necessarily!
These are two alternatives you can use to receive internet freedom in China:
Data-Roaming with a Foreign SIM Card
Buy a data-roaming SIM from any foreign country or simply from Hong Kong.
You can find many SIM cards that have data roaming activated from eBay for as low as $19.99.These SIMs have their own data plans. Usually, they come with a 1.5GB data limitation.
However, you can opt for a more suitable plan, if it comes under your budget. One of the best China Data SIMs I recommend is from a company called GMHK.
You can get the SIM from this eBay link here for $19.99. Shipping costs may add $5.99. Simply add the SIM in your phone and enjoy unblocking all your favorite apps/websites/services without any hassle!
Created by a Chinese programmer called “Clowwindy”, the ShadowSocks Proxy is a free and open-source encrypted proxy project. It is used very commonly in mainland China.
This because of its ability to anonymize your network. Unlike other proxies, ShadowSocks does utilize encryption. This allows users from around the world to bypass firewalls
The best part of all: you do not have to pay a single penny for using the ShadowSocks Proxy. You can try it by clicking here.
States in China that Do Not Require a VPN Service
Hong Kong and Macau are famous destinations for many, thanks to their amazing nightlife, modern architecture, vibrant lifestyle, and. modern architecture. With skyscraper-studded skylines and beautiful year-round weather, the two states are bound to impress visitors/tourists.
However, not many people are aware that Hong Kong and Macau even exist as the safest locations in terms of internet censorship laws. Where China blocks all access to the outside world, Hong Kong and Macau believe in a FREE lifestyle.
Residents of both states do not have to face the torment of a walled-off internet. However, this still does not mean that the Government or Communist Party is not watching your every move.
Also, there is not much time until the agreement between both states with China regarding internet laws and censorship changes. Subsequently, it is still imperative for residents and expats living in the country to invest in a reliable VPN solution for protecting their digital identity!
How to Protect Yourself from Government Surveillance in China
The “Great Firewall of China” has amassed a great reputation for being incredibly hard to penetrate, preventing users within the country from accessing services in other countries.
The Government tries its best in controlling what content is available for seeing to its citizens. In light of this, they indulge in internet surveillance activities. Follow the steps below to protect yourself:
- Keep All Data Off the Cloud –Hacking personal accounts is not a difficult task for government agencies. Since nowadays everyone backs up their data online, this poses a great risk. All your passwords, documents, and pictures could become part of the internet data lump. Try moving all your personal information to a secure external hard drive or USB, preferably encrypted.
- Use End-to-End Encryption –For protecting all your private conversations, it is crucial to use end-to-end encryption. One of the most famous tools that offer this feature is “off-the-record (OTR) messaging), which adds a layer of encryption to all text messages sent and received via Facebook Chat and Google Hangout. You can even install it on your desktop PCs.
- Add Strong Passwords to All Accounts –Whether it’s your email, social media, or any other account, make sure to always keep strong passwords with a mix of alphabets, numbers, and various characters. To further boost your safety, instead of storing your passwords online or on your PC, consider writing them done on a piece of paper.
- Use VPN over Tor Configuration –Using a VPN is one of the best ways to boost your online security. However, nothing beats the VPN over Tor configuration by adding an extra layer of privacy! Since your network passes through double encryptions that travel across thousands of nodes around the world, it is almost impossible to trace your identity.
- Use Anti-Virus/Malware Software –Many anti-virus and malware solutions come equipped with advanced tools and threat detection systems that disable the network upon identifying any kind of attack. Bear in mind some viruses/malware have the ability to create copies of your personal data and sending them elsewhere. Using such software is crucial for guaranteeing complete safety!
What Sites are Blocked in China? Updated List 2019
By the end of 2017, Mainland China managed to block over 3,000 websites from around the world, under the country’s infamous internet censorship policy. We have compiled a list of some of the important ones below, but if you want a complete overview, check this link out.
Apps block in China
When in China, you cannot access certain apps for communication. These include KaKao Talk, the freeware app LINE, and even WhatsApp. The country even blocks Google Play and related services, which means you cannot access apps like Calendar, Gmail, Docs, Drive, and Translate.
Work Tools block in China
China blocks many popular tool websites like Android, Xing, Scribd, WayBackMachine, iStock Photos, ShutterStock, Dropbox, VPNs, Microsoft OneDrive, Feedburner, Twitter URL Shortener, Google URL Shortener, Bit.ly, OpenVPN, ThePirateBay, 4Shared, Change.org, PasteBin, and Archive.org.
Popular Websites block in China
You completely lose access to various websites like VPN Coupons, Slack, Yahoo, Skype and anything linked to the outside world. Heck, this even includes SoundCloud. You will not be able to listen to your favorite music on the website.
Social Media Sites Block in China
Of course, if the country has taken measures to block access to websites worldwide, it also made sure to include social media. You cannot access Hootsuite, Google Hangouts, Google+, Flickr, Blogger, BlogSpot, WordPress.com, Picasa, Snapchat, Tumblr, Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook.
Search Engines Block in China
Google, and all versions of the search engine, which include Google.com/ncr, Google.de, and Google.hk will be inaccessible. In addition to this, China has even blocked various versions of Yahoo, Baidu, and Duck Duck Go. You will have to rely on Bing primarily!
Video Sharing Sites Block in China
Perhaps the most depressing of all is the inability to access Snapchat, Instagram, Periscope, Twitch, Daily Motion, Vimeo, Netflix, YouTube, BBC iPlayer, Amazon Prime, and even porn websites, without exception. You will only be able to access Chinese content.
Media/Magazines Block in China
China also makes sure you have no way to learn about the happenings in other countries. The country blocks Wikipedia, WikiLeaks, Google News, L-Equipe, LeMonde, Reuters, Bloomberg, The Economist, The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, The Independent, and The Guardian.
Data Retention Law and Urge of VPNs in China
As compared to the previous rather regressive and controlling laws, China has now introduced the long-awaited “National Standards on Information Security Technology”.
Enforced on May 1st, this new law will act as the de facto standard for handling and retaining information, while clarifying under what circumstances your data will be recorded.
Typically, under the Cybersecurity law, explicit consent will be required for the collection/use of personal information.
This indicates that network operators no longer have the ability to disclose, processing, storing or collecting personal information unless you give your permission.
If “consent” is not provided, data processing is only permissible in circumstances where the identity of the said person is anonymized, ensuring the information cannot be restored to its original state.
However, despite China significantly improving its data retention laws, it is still quite a jumble to trust that your information is not under government surveillance.
The most favored content in China is in their regional language i.e. Mandarin but as of now, Chinese people are also exploring translated content in English, which has made the authorities cramp down on this sort of content as its “external influences” are not in line with Chinese Government regulations.
China Planning to Ease Internet Censorship – Fake News or True?
There are plenty of rumors circulating that China is working its way towards easing internet censorship. However, sorry to burst your bubble lads, this news still needs to be vetted, after all, China is an authoritarian Communist dystopia. Though not entirely false, there are talks about softening internet laws in at least one province, with still a lot of details to be revealed.
How did the rumors spread? On June 21st, the Chinese Communist Party introduced a three-year plan for transforming the South Island province of Hainan into a FREE trading port. Along with plenty of other suggestions, one involved the permission to access certain websites, which are currently inaccessible/blocked – thanks to the “Great Firewall of China”.
To attract more tourists and visitors to Hainan, the plan recommended unrestricted access to social media sites like Twitter, YouTube, and Facebook, albeit not for the locals but only the people visiting. All details were uploaded by the local government website but were taken down after a day, leaving many unsure whether this suggestion was a rumor, online error, or actually a genuine proposal.
According to the South China Morning Post, the report is still in approval-process by the CCP-controlled state media, meaning there is still discussion/debate going on about it. So while entire China may not get ease from the strict internet laws, you might have hope for Hainan. This just goes to show how China’s own online censorship is having a negative effect on the economy, especially in the tourism sector.
Best VPN for China Reddit Reviews (Is Reddit Blocked in China?)
You can find many threads on Reddit discussing the unfair policies of China concerning internet censorship. Residents and people visiting the country are often contemplating about which VPN service to use for bypassing blocks to services like Google. According to one user, China may also block access to VPNs by February 2018, but this news was disposed to be a rumor. Check out best reddit vpn for more VPN reviews and recommendations
If you are looking for advice regarding good VPN services to use in China, you can follow the thread below. As you can see, you will find many comments of users of different VPNs. Their experiences with various providers can help you make an informed decision, regarding which provider you want to go with, based on the information we provided and you analyzed.
Proxy vs. VPN – What’s the Best for China?
Proxy services use a server for routing your network traffic through its IP address. VPNs, on the other hand, use a more sophisticated mechanism. In addition to shifting your location and masking your IP address, they also offer high-level encryption. This ensures that your data is unreadable to cybercriminals, spy agencies, hackers, and ISPs. Based on this, VPNs are undoubtedly the best choice for China.
Best VPN Protocol to Use in China?
If you want to leverage exceptional security while in China, then you can only rely on the OpenVPN protocol, which comes equipped with AES 256-bit encryption keys, SHA512 authorization, and 2048-bit Key Encryption. Some providers like NordVPN and ExpressVPN even go the extra mile in boosting the security by using 4096-bit Key Encryption instead. As another option, you can even consider the L2TP/IPSec protocol, which offers more or less the same level of security.
Best VPN for China FAQs
Though we made sure to cover all bases in our guide for the best VPN for China, you can still present queries/questions. Below you can find a series of common questions, we get asked a lot regarding VPNs in China and the country’s internet laws. So, we decided to list them done in a single location:
Is Facebook still banned in China??
The Government of China decided to block Facebook in the early July of 2009, due to the Ürümqi riots, which ended up becoming a serious issue. Those who were supporters of the Xinjiang Independence were found to use Facebook as part of their communications network.
Can You Get On Google in China?
Yes, you can definitely access Google and its services in China, despite them being blocked in the country. The only solution as mentioned in the blog is to use a VPN. By masking your IP address and making it appear you are located in another country, you can easily bypass internet censorship.
Is Gmail Forbidden in China?
China has the world’s strongest internet censorship program. It blocks any and everything that provides access to foreign-based tech or information. This includes Google and its services like Gmail. However, you can unblock the website by using a VPN service. For more information, you can read our blog here. Read more details about how to unblock Gmail in China
Can I use my Instagram in China?
Instagram is a fun platform for sharing photos about the latest happenings in your daily life. If you are just visiting China, you will find that the SM platform is blocked. This means you will not be able to share pictures with your family members/friends. VPNs are the solution to unblocking Instagram.
What is Best VPN for Travel to China?
If you are traveling to China, then you probably know the importance of using a VPN. These handy tools are the only solution to reconnecting with your family members and friends. Some of the best providers include NordVPN, IPVanish, PrivateVPN, Ivacy, and PureVPN.
Do VPNs Work in China?
Though the Chinese Government has been taking strict action against VPN providers and users by removing apps from the local iTunes and Google Play Store and jailing citizens for simply unblocking websites, VPNs still work in China. Yes, this does depend on the provider you choose, but most services offer a workaround to using VPN apps on their smartphones, desktops, and laptops.
Is Snapchat allowed in China?
Snapchat similar to all other social media apps like Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Blogspot, Flickr, Periscope, Tinder, and Google+ cannot be accessible if you are located in China. The only workaround to using these apps is to unblock them via a powerful VPN service, which uses strong encryption and advanced features for bypassing content-restrictions! Learn how to use Snapchat in China @ BestVPN.co
Is Netflix Available In China?
Though Netflix itself is not accessible within China, due to content-limitations of the country, the top premium service did enter into a licensing deal with Baidu’s iQiyi – a famous video portal that enjoys more than 500 million monthly viewers. Now users in China have the capability of watching some Netflix content via the iQiyi app.
Is Spotify banned in China?
Sadly, there is bad news here too. The Chinese Government takes its local reputation very seriously and always tries coming up with solutions that work for their own citizens only. Subsequently, the Spotify app/website is not accessible within the country. You will have to use a VPN service to bypass the content-restriction.
Wrapping Things Up
Hosting the most powerful censorship regime in the world, China is a tough country to live in. Though there are alternatives to all websites/services blocked, it is highly irritating not being able to access the ones you actually want to. This is where VPNs come in, providing a sigh of relief in a tough online climate. Use the recommended providers to regain control of the internet!
Each VPN listed above has been selected after careful research, testing, and analysis. We strive to be as accurate as possible with the complexities of the “Great Firewall” and China’s confused mindset concerning “dedicated lines”. Nevertheless, do feel free to give your own suggestions about best VPN for China or share your experience with any of the providers mentioned above.